Snap/Snappier Judgement

« Prev
1
Next »

Kay4077
General

Bearer of A 600 Posts Medal

Winner of A Special Commendation

Giving a whole new meaning to 'soap star'[M:0]

Posts: 787

Snap/Snappier Judgement Feb 13, 2006 19:45:36 GMT

Post by Kay4077 on Feb 13, 2006 19:45:36 GMT

I have mixed feelings about these episodes. On the one hand, it's always nice to see Charles in his dress uniform. And I LOVE that all-too-brief shot of him smiling for the camera in 'Snap Judgement'.

But I do detest the way 'Snappier Judgement' goes - are we really supposed to believe that a guy as intelligent as Charles would make such a complete horlicks of Klinger's defence? Unfortunately, he has to be made to look an idiot so that St Hawkeye (and his sidekick, BJ the Whinge) can save the day. Again. ::)

::)

I'm not getting off this cot till the ground stops moving! (Charles Emerson Winchester)

Jenna
Veteran

Bearer of A 1000 Posts Medal

Competition Winners Medal

[M:0]

Posts: 1,630

Snap/Snappier Judgement Feb 13, 2006 19:52:10 GMT

Post by Jenna on Feb 13, 2006 19:52:10 GMT

kay4077 said:

I have mixed feelings about these episodes. On the one hand, it's always nice to see Charles in his dress uniform. And I LOVE that all-too-brief shot of him smiling for the camera in 'Snap Judgement'.

I can't wait to get a screen cap of that one. He's got such a lovely smile in that scene.

But I do detest the way 'Snappier Judgement' goes - are we really supposed to believe that a guy as intelligent as Charles would make such a complete horlicks of Klinger's defence? Unfortunately, he has to be made to look an idiot so that St Hawkeye (and his sidekick, BJ the Whinge) can save the day. Again. ::)

::)

You're not the only one. I hate the way they make Charles look like a fool just so Hawk and BJ can come in to save the day.